/chartertit.gif)
PRINCIPLES
FOR CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION OF BUILT HERITAGE
Recognising the contribution of individuals and institutions who,
in the course of three years, have participated in the preparation of
the International Conference on Conservation "Krakow 2000"
and its Plenary Session "Cultural Heritage as the Foundation of
the Development of Civilisation",
We, the participants of the International Conference on Conservation
"Krakow 2000", conscious of the profound meanings associated
with cultural heritage, submit the following principles to those responsible
for heritage as a guideline for the efforts to safeguard such properties.
PREAMBLE
Acting in the spirit of the Charter of Venice, taking note of the international
recommendations and urged on by the process of European unification,
at the turn of the new millennium, we are conscious of living within
such a framework, in which identities, in an ever more extensive context,
are becoming characterised and more distinct. Europe today is characterised
by a cultural diversity and thus by the plurality of fundamental values
related to the mobile, immobile and intellectual heritage, the different
meanings associated with it and consequently also conflicts of interest.
This obliges all those responsible for safeguarding cultural heritage
to become increasingly attentive to the problems and choices they need
to face in pursuing their objectives.
Each community, by means of its collective memory
and consciousness of its past, is responsible for the identification
as well as the management of its heritage. Individual elements of this
heritage are bearers of
many values, which may change in time. The various specific values in
the elements characterise the specificity of each heritage. From this
process of change, each community develops an awareness and consciousness
of a need to look after their own common heritage values.
This heritage cannot be defined in a fixed way. One can only define
the way in which the heritage may be identified. Plurality in society
entails a great diversity in heritage
concepts as conceived by the entire community; therefore the tools and
methods developed for appropriate preservation should be adapted to
the evolving situations, which are subject to a process
of continual change. The particular context of selecting
these values requires the preparation of a conservation
plan and a series of decisions. These should be codified
in a restoration project according
to appropriate technical and structural criteria.
Conscious of the profound values of the Charter of Venice and working
towards the same aims, we propose the following principles for conservation
and restoration of the built heritage in our time.
AIMS
AND METHODS
1. The architectural, urban and
landscape heritage, as well as artefacts, are the result of an identification
with various associated moments in history and social-cultural contexts.
The conservation of this heritage is our aim. Conservation
can be realised by different types of interventions such as environmental
control, maintenance, repair, restoration , renovation and rehabilitation.
Any intervention implies decisions, selections and responsibilities
related to the complete heritage, also to those parts that may not have
a specific meaning today, but might have one in the future.
2. Maintenance and repairs are a
fundamental part of the process of heritage conservation. These actions
have to be organised with systematic research, inspection, control,
monitoring and testing. Possible decay has to be foreseen and reported
on, and appropriate preventive measures have to be taken.
3. The conservation of built heritage
is implemented by the project of restoration,
including the strategy to conserve in the long term. This `restoration
project` should be based on a range of appropriate technical options
and prepared in a cognitive process of gathering knowledge and understanding
of the building or site. This may include traditional and subsequent
new materials, structural investigations, graphical and dimensional
analysis and the identification of historical, artistic and socio-cultural
significance. All pertinent disciplines have to participate in the restoration
project and the co-ordination should be carried out by a person qualified
and well trained in conservation and restoration.
4. The reconstruction of entire
parts 'in the style of the building' should be avoided. Reconstruction
of very small parts having architectural significance can be acceptable
as an exception on condition that it is based on precise and indisputable
documentation. If necessary, for a proper use of the building, completion
of more extensive spatial and functional parts should reflect contemporary
architecture. Reconstruction of an entire building, destroyed by armed
conflict or natural disaster, is only acceptable if there are exceptional
social or cultural motives that are related to the identity of the entire
community.
DIFFERENT
KINDS OF BUILT HERITAGE
5. Any intervention involving the archaeological heritage,
due to its vulnerability, should be strictly related to its surroundings,
territory and landscape. The destructive aspects of the excavation should
be reduced as far as possible. At each excavation, the archaeological
work must be fully documented.
As in all other cases, conservation work on archaeological finds must
be based on the principle of minimum intervention. This must be done
by professionals and the methodology and techniques used must be strictly
controlled.
In the protection and public presentation of archaeological sites, the
use of modern technologies, databanks, information systems and virtual
presentation techniques should be promoted.
6. The purpose of conservation of
historic buildings and monuments,
whether in the urban or rural context, is to maintain their authenticity
and integrity, including internal spaces, furnishings and decoration
according to their original appearance. Such conservation requires an
appropriate `project of restoration` that defines the methods and aims.
In many cases, it also requires an appropriate use, compatible with
the existing space and significance. Work on historic buildings must
pay full attention to all the periods that are present.
7. Architectural decoration, sculpture and
artefacts that are an integrated part of the built heritage
should be preserved through a specific project connected to the general
project. This presupposes that the restorer has the proper knowledge
and training in addition to the cultural, technical and operating capacity
to interpret the different analyses of the specific artistic fields.
The restoration project must guarantee a correct approach to the conservation
of the full setting, decoration or sculpture, with respect to traditional
building crafts and their necessary integration as a substantial part
of the built heritage.
8. Historic towns and villages,
in their territorial setting, represent an essential part of our universal
heritage, and should be seen as a whole with the structures, spaces
and human factors, normally in the process of continuous evolution and
change. This involves all sectors of the population, and requires an
integrated planning process, consisting of a wider range of different
activities. Conservation in the urban context deals with ensembles of
buildings and open spaces, which are part of larger urban areas, or
of entire small urban or rural settlements, including intangible values.
In this context, intervention consists of referring to the city in its
morphological, functional and structural whole, as part of its territory,
its environment and surrounding landscape. The buildings that form historic
areas may not have a special architectural value in themselves, but
they should be safeguarded because of their organic unity, distinctive
dimensions, and their technological, spatial, decorative and chromatic
characteristics as connecting elements.
The restoration project of the historic town
or village should anticipate the management of change, in
addition to verifying the sustainability of selected options, linking
heritage issues with social and economic aspects. Apart from obtaining
knowledge of the structures, there is the need for a study of the influences
of change and the tools required for the management process. The project
of restoration for historic areas regards the buildings of the urban
fabric in their twofold function: a) the elements that define the spaces
of the city within its urban form, and b) the internal spatial arrangements
that are an essential part of the building.
9. Landscapes as cultural heritage
result from and reflect a prolonged interaction in different societies
between man, nature and the physical environment. They are testimony
to the evolving relationship of communities, individuals and their environment.
In this context their conservation, preservation and development focus
on human and natural features, integrating material and intangible values.
It is important to understand and respect the character of landscapes,
and apply appropriate laws and norms to harmonise relevant territorial
functions with essential values. In many societies, landscapes are historically
related to urban territories and influences.
The integration of cultural landscape conservation, and the sustainable
development of regions and localities with ecological activities, and
the natural environment require awareness and understanding of the relationships
over time. This involves making links with the built environment of
the metropolis, city and town.
Integrated conservation of fossil and archaeological landscapes, and
the development of a highly dynamic landscapes, involve social, cultural
and aesthetic values.
10. Conservation/preservation techniques
should be strictly tied to interdisciplinary scientific research on
materials and technologies used for the construction, repair and/or
restoration of the built heritage. The chosen intervention should respect
the original function and ensure compatibility with existing materials,
structures and architectural values. Any new materials and technologies
should be rigorously tested, compared and understood before application.
Although the in situ application of new techniques may be relevant to
the continued well-being of original fabric, they should be continually
monitored in the light of the achieved results, taking into account
their behaviour over time and the possibility of eventual reversibility.
Particular attention is required to improve our knowledge of traditional
materials and techniques, and their appropriate continuation in the
context of modern society, being in themselves important components
of cultural heritage.
MANAGEMENT
11. The
management of dynamic change, transformation and development of historic
cities and the cultural heritage in general, consists of appropriate
regulation, making choices, and monitoring outcomes. As an essential
part of this process, it is necessary to identify risks, anticipate
appropriate prevention systems, and create emergency plans of action.
Cultural tourism, beside its positive aspects on the local economy,
should be considered as such a risk. Attention should also be paid to
the optimisation of running costs.
Conservation of cultural heritage should be an integral part of the
planning and management processes of a community, as it can contribute
to the sustainable, qualitative, economic and social developments of
that society.
12. The plurality of heritage values
and diversity of interests necessitates a communication structure that
allows, in addition to specialists and administrators, an effective
participation of inhabitants in the process. It is the responsibility
of communities to establish appropriate methods and structures to ensure
true participation of individuals and institutions in the decision-making
process.
TRAINING
AND EDUCATION
13. Training and education in cultural
heritage matters requires social involvement and integration into national
systems of education at all levels. The complexity of a restoration
project, or any other conservation intervention, involving historic,
technical, cultural and economic aspects requires the appointment of
a competent and well educated leader.
Education of conservators must be interdisciplinary and involve accurate
study of architectural history, theory and techniques of conservation.
This should assure the appropriate qualifications necessary to resolve
research problems needed to carry out conservation and restoration interventions
in a professional and responsible way.
The training of professionals and technicians in the conservation disciplines
should take full account of evolving methodologies and technical knowledge,
and be aware of the on-going debate on conservation theories and policies.
The quality of craft and technical work during restoration projects
should also be enhanced by improved vocational training.
LEGAL
MEASURES
14. The protection and conservation of the built heritage
could be better enabled if greater legal and administrative actions
are taken. This should be aimed at ensuring the conservation work is
only undertaken by, or under the supervision of, conservation professionals.
Legal regulations might also make provision for a period of practical
experience in a structured programme. Consideration should be given
to newly-trained conservators obtaining a permit for independent practice.
This should be gained under the supervision of conservation professionals.
ANNEX
- DEFINITIONS
The redaction committee of this "CHARTER OF KRAKOW" used following
terminological concepts :
a.
Heritage:
Heritage is that complex of man's works in which a community recognises
its particular and specific values and with which it identifies. Identification
and specification of heritage is therefore a process related to the
choice of values.
b. Monument: A monument is an entity
identified as of worth and forming a support to memory. In it, memory
recognises aspects that are pertinent to human deeds and thoughts, associated
with the historic time line. This may still be within our reach, even
though not yet interpreted.
c. Authenticity means the sum of
substantial, historically ascertained characteristics: from the original
up to the current state, as an outcome of the various transformations
that have occurred over time.
d. Identity is understood as the
common reference of both present values generated in the sphere of a
community and past values identified in its authenticity.
e. Conservation: Conservation is
the complex of attitudes of a community that contributes to making the
heritage and its monuments endure. Conservation is achieved with reference
to the significance of the entity, with its associated values.
f. Restoration: Restoration is an
operation directed on a heritage property, aiming at the conservation
of its authenticity and its appropriation by the community.
g. Project of restoration: The project,
resulting from the choice of conservation policies, is the process through
which conservation of the built heritage and landscape is carried out.